Olive Co Reviews

Olive Co has an overall rating of 2.6 based on 16 reviews. Customer feedback on Olive Co is mixed.

2.6/5.0

16 reviews

5 Stars

1

4 Stars

4

3 Stars

5

2 Stars

0

1 Star

6

All Olive Co Reviews (16)
Tamara-chartier
May 18, 2026
"bad communication and no follow up"
getting a response felt like it took forever. i had to keep chasing things myself, and no one really followed up the way they should have. it got frustrating
CharlesSisneros
May 13, 2026
"Works Well for Me So Far"
I’ve used the site a bit and, from my experience, it seems reliable. I haven’t run into any major issues, and it gives me enough confidence to keep using it...
Bryan.coronado
May 12, 2026
"Pretty okay, but not perfect"
Signing up was literally super easy, which I appreciated. The only downside was that the claim updates felt kind of slow, so I had to wait longer than I expected
stephany_Button75
May 01, 2026
"Coverage options felt limited"
I was expecting a bit more when it came to coverage choices, but the options were just okay. It would be nice to see more flexibility, i’d hope there’s some kind of compensation or credit if the plan doesn’t really meet what was advertised.
GladysSinger_97
April 28, 2026
"I’m usually skeptical when companies..."
I’m usually skeptical when companies make everything sound super polished and perfect, so I didn’t expect much going in. But the plans were actually cheaper than I thought they’d be, and support was fine when I needed it. Nothing blew me away, but for the price, it feels like a solid deal overall.
ValerieHaid
April 18, 2026
"Quick quote and easy enough to use"
I tried olive.com the other night after dinner because I was already on my laptop paying a couple bills and figured I might as well see what a quote would look like. it was simple. The questions were straightforward and it didn’t take very long to get through, which I appreciated because I wasn’t in the mood to sit there forever. I do wish a few of the coverage details were explained a little more clearly before moving on, since I had to pause and think about what some of it meant. Overall though, it worked fine. Not totally perfect, but definitely better than having to call and talk to someone
william2001
March 09, 2026
"Pretty smooth overall, but the emails were slow"
I was able to buy the plan without any real issues, and the website was fairly easy to use. That said, the enrollment emails took longer to come through than I expected, and a few parts of the site weren’t as clear as they could’ve been. Overall though, I got it done and the process was okay.
Amanda.funderburke
March 02, 2026
"Still waiting for my refund"
I canceled my olive.com plan and was told my refund would be processed in a few days, but it’s been weeks now. I don’t want to say they’re completely unhelpful, because the support team has been polite and quick enough to respond, but the replies are always kind of vague and nothing really changes.
It’s frustrating because part of me thinks it’s probably just some system delay, but i shouldn’t have to keep following up to get my own money back. I liked the service well enough at first, and maybe they’re fine when everything goes smoothly, but after this experience I don’t see myself using them again.
candice_Collier94
February 27, 2026
"Too Many Waiting Periods for My Situation"
This just didn’t end up being a good fit for me. After I signed up, I realized there were waiting periods and quite a few things that weren’t covered. From my perspective, it felt like almost everything I asked about had some kind of exclusion. I probably should’ve read the details more carefully upfront, but the whole experience was frustrating, and for me, it didn’t feel worth it.
danielle_Mautone00
February 07, 2026
"Contract details were kind of hard to follow"
I wasn’t a fan of how the contract info was laid out on Olive.com. I just wanted to understand what I was signing up for, but it felt like I kept having to click around, then go back, then check another section.

Some of the terms didn’t really feel clear to me, especially around fees and what was actually covered. And then I started wondering about cancellation stuff too, which made the whole thing feel more confusing than it needed to be.

Maybe all the information is technically there somewhere, I’m not saying it isn’t. But it should be much easier to find before you sign anything. It just left me feeling unsure, and not great about moving forward
Yvette-ohlsen
February 04, 2026
"Pretty good, but finding a shop was a hassle"
The coverage was decent overall, but my usual repair shop wouldn’t accept it at first, which was a little frustrating. I had to make a few calls before I found a shop that would take it, so that part was kind of a pain.
Robert-jantz
January 25, 2026
"Olive made the payment process way harder than it needed to be"
I tried using olive.com i was annoyed by how limited the payment options were. I figured they’d at least have something like split payments or a few more flexible choices, but they really don’t. That’s on Olive, in my opinion, if your system only works for people who fit one exact payment setup, you’re going to leave a lot of customers stuck. I reached out to support too, but they mostly just gave me generic answers and didn’t really help. Overall, it felt unnecessarily frustrating.
hello_jane241
January 15, 2026
"I know some people might get impatient, but..."
I know some people might get impatient, but i did get reimbursed in the end. It took longer than I would’ve liked, sure, but it’s not like they ignored me completely. The payment eventually came through, so I can’t really say they didn’t follow up.
Kristen_rosenberg01
January 14, 2026
"Claim approved quickly and stress-free"
I was really happy with how easy the whole claim process was. It got approved faster than I expected, and everything went so smoothly with no hassle at all.
judith1982
December 30, 2025
"Claim was denied, but the explanation was fair"
My claim ended up getting denied because they said the damage was pre-existing. Not the outcome I was hoping for, but the staff explained it clearly and quickly, which I appreciated. For anyone else dealing with a claim, I’d suggest having photos and records ready from before and after the issue, just to avoid any confusion.
james.Mcfarland
December 09, 2025
"First impression wasn’t great"
My first impression was disappointing. I reached out to customer service and then didn’t hear anything back for days, which made me feel ignored. It’s frustrating when you’re just waiting for a simple reply.
Have a question about Olive Co?

Customer Reviews

Ask a Question

Welcome to WorthEPenny.com! We use cookies to better understand your preferences, optimize our website and services, enhance user experiences, personalize content and ads, and provide social media and other third-party features. If you want to learn more about cookies and why we use them, visit our Cookie Policy page.